IN THE MATTER OF THE POLICE CONDUCT REGULATIONS 2020
AND IN THE MATTER OF AN ACCELERATED MISCONDUCT HEARING
RE: Former PC Chris Browne
DETERMINATION OF CHIEF CONSTABLE VANESSA JARDINE
- This is my determination in the accelerated misconduct proceedings relating to Former Officer PC Chris Browne (‘the Former Officer’). References in square brackets indicate pages of the hearing bundle.
Representation
- The Appropriate Authority was represented by Helen Thompson. The Former Officer did not attend the hearing, and was not represented by his fed rep. He confirmed he did not wish to be represented.
Allegations
- The Former Officer faces allegations set out in the Regulation 51 notice [32] which states that:
- It is alleged that, between 27 September 2024 and 13 May 2025 you ‘key jammed’ on a total of at least 124 separate occasions by predominately opening a Teams chat message before pressing, via an unknown means, the right-hand arrow key for a prolonged period, triggering a high character count.
- It is further alleged that the purpose of your actions, as set out in allegation 1, was to give the impression that you were active on the force’s computer systems and completing work.
- It is alleged that such conduct was a breach of the Standards of Professional Behaviour relating to Honesty and Integrity, Duties and Responsibilities and Orders and Instructions.
- The former Officer has not provided a response to the allegations and has expressly stated that they would not engage with the proceedings.
Burden and standard of proof
- The burden of proof is on the Appropriate Authority to prove that the former officer behaved in the manner alleged and that in doing so, he breached the standards of professional behaviour. The standard of proof is on the balance of probabilities. The Appropriate Authority must further satisfy me that the manner of the breach is of such a nature or degree that it amounts to gross misconduct.
Determination of conduct
- In making my determination in relation to the alleged misconduct, I have assessed all relevant information made available to me in the hearing bundle.
- I have also utilised the relevant sections of the College of Policing Document ‘Guidance on Outcomes in Police Misconduct Proceedings’ in formulating the rationale for my determination.
- Before making my determination, I reminded myself of the definition of misconduct and gross misconduct as prescribed by Regulation 2.
- It is alleged that the former Officer has key jammed keys on his keyboard, leaving the weight in place for a considerable period of time, in order to give the misleading impression that he was working.
- The evidence before me shows that the Former Officer was working remotely at the time of these allegations.
- Between the 2nd April 2025 and the 16th April 2025, an alert was sent due to the Former Officer had duplicated over 100,000 keystrokes. This came from holding down the right arrow key. An Audit commenced of the officer’s laptop from the 1st January 2024 until the 13th May 2025, predominantly whilst using teams. This was done on 124 occasions between the 27th September 2025 and the 13th May 2025.
- As a way of an example, at its most extreme this included holding a key down for 3 hours and 26 minutes continuously [18].
- I am therefore satisfied that this is proven on the balance of probabilities.
- I am satisfied that the former officer knew that he was being paid to be at work, was not working during those times. I am satisfied on balance of probabilities that the former was dishonest.
- As the AA outlined, there is no expectation that officers working from home work continuously without a break. Breaks are taken in an office environment, and they can and should be taken when working from home. In modern life, it is accepted that people can and will attend to brief household chore during such breaks. However, the difference in this case is the pattern, the prolonged periods of non-police activity, the numbers of such days and the repeated periods of this conduct. The actions and decisions of the Former Officer are of a different character.
- I am satisfied on balance of probabilities that the former officer knew that he should not have been weighing down his laptop. His action of weighing down keys provided an objectively misleading picture of his conduct, making him appear as if he was working. I am satisfied on balance of probabilities that an ordinary decent person would regard these matters as dishonest, as they are claiming to be working, and taking a wage and accruing benefits, whilst doing something else. I am satisfied that the former officer’s conduct as set out was a breach of the Standards of Professional Behaviour related to Honesty and Integrity.
- I am also satisfied that the conduct breaches the standards for Order and Instructions and Duties and responsibilities, for the same reasons set out previously.
Severity
- I have considered Section 4 of the Home Office guidance on Outcomes. I have first considered the level of culpability for the Former Officer. As described at paragraph 4.10, conduct which is “intentional, deliberate, targeted or planned will generally be more culpable than conduct that has unintended consequences”. In this case, given the systemic nature of The Former Officer’s conduct, it can only be described as intentional and deliberate. The Former Officer could also be regarded as being in a position of responsibility as he was trusted to work from home. As set out at paragraph 4.30 Cases involving any form of dishonesty on duty will always be serious because of the importance of maintaining public trust and confidence in the police service. I therefore assess the culpability as High.
- When considering the level of harm, I note paragraph 4.66 of the guidance which states “Where an officer commits an act that would harm public confidence if the circumstances were known to the public, take this into account. Always take misconduct seriously that undermines discipline and good order within the police service, even if it does not result in harm to individual victims”. Conduct of this nature would plainly have a substantial impact on public confidence. If the conduct had been a one off or occasional and only for a brief period of time, the level of harm would be lower. However, the Former Officer’s conduct was repeated and for prolonged periods, over many days and months. The level of harm is therefore high.
- I also considered the list of aggravating features in this case as set out at paragraph 4.76, and other factors not listed. Factors I consider aggravating (where not already listed to avoid double counting) are:
- Multiple incidents and multiple breaches
- No evidence of the officer stopping their conduct voluntarily.
- However, I take the view this would be double counting what has already been included within the culpability and harm section. I therefore do not aggravate it further.
- In terms of mitigation, none applies in this case. I have considered this even though the Former Officer has not made representations that it applies.
- I have given specific consideration as to whether the misconduct is at the level of gross misconduct or at the level of simple misconduct. Having assessed the seriousness of the Former Officer’s actions, I am satisfied that the misconduct would have been so serious as to justify dismissal and so constitutes gross misconduct. The conduct on display by the Former Officer was persistent and over a prolonged period. The impact of that behaviour on the public’s trust and confidence in the police would be substantial. The trust and confidence of other officers in the Former Officer would be equally undermined. I am therefore satisfied that the only appropriate assessment is that the behaviour amounts to Gross Misconduct.
Finding
- In conclusion, my findings are that these allegations are proven in full on the balance of probabilities and that the proven misconduct breaches the Standards of Professional Behaviour alleged, namely Honesty and Integrity, Duties and Responsibilities and Orders and Instructions and that such proven breaches constitute gross misconduct.
Determination of outcome
- Having determined that these allegations amounted to gross misconduct, I invited representations from the Appropriate Authority. Had the Former Officer been represented, I would have heard representations from them as well. In the circumstances, I have had the Former Officer’s interests in mind to ensure any mitigation applied fairly.
- Submissions were made by the Appropriate Authority that the appropriate outcome in this case would be disciplinary action.
- Any action I take today has to balance the officer’s rights proportionately with the requirement to maintain public confidence, and to deter misconduct. My role is not punitive, and is not to punish Former PC Chris Browne.
- I have considered the seriousness of the misconduct that gave rise to the officer’s appearance at the hearing today, in accordance with the College of Policing’s Guidance on Outcomes, and set out my conclusions and the reasons for them below.
Culpability
- I have considered the officer’s culpability in this case and make the following observations:
- I have found that the officer’s conduct was intentional and occurred over a prolonged period.
- He accrued pay and benefits and the dishonesty occurred whilst he was on shift.
- I again remind myself of the Guidance on outcomes, in particular paragraph 4.30, which states “Cases involving any form of dishonesty on duty will always be serious because of the importance of maintaining public trust and confidence in the police service”
- I therefore assess this Officer’s culpability as high.
Harm
- I have considered the harm caused by the Officer’s actions in this case and make the following observations:
- There is significant harm to public confidence and the reputation of Police and policing in general. The conduct undertaken by the former officer fails to reach the standards of police officers that is expected by members of the public, and would draw significant criticism from them. They would view it as an abuse of the public’s trust and confidence by not working when being paid to do so.
- Given that the conduct occurred on many occasions and for long periods of time, the harm is heightened.
- The conduct would also impact on other officers who do not have the same privileges to work from home and their perception of fairness, and whether they could rely on the Former Officer in future.
- I find therefore that the harm in this case was high.
Aggravating Factors
- I have carefully considered the aggravating factors listed within the guidance and any other issues outside of those which may be said to have aggravated the actions he took. However, counting for these would amount to double counting. I therefore do not aggravate them further.
Mitigation
- No mitigation has been advanced. I have considered the papers with care, and I cannot locate any mitigation on the papers. Whilst there has been reference to mental ill health, it is not substantiated with any evidence that allows me to consider its relevance to the conduct and I therefore cannot give it any real weight when assessing mitigation.
Determination
- I find that the appropriate outcome in this case would have been dismissal without notice had the officer still been serving.
- Under Regulation 62 of the Regulations, I must impose disciplinary action which must be dismissal without notice unless exceptional circumstances exist to justify a lesser sanction. As amended by schedule 1, where I find gross misconduct I must impose disciplinary action.
- Having considered the papers, I cannot identify any exceptional circumstances which exist in this case. Nor can I identify any reason which would allow me to step back from imposing disciplinary action.
- Therefore, I have determined that I need to impose disciplinary action in this case. That can only be that the officer would have been dismissed had they still continued to serve as a police officer.
- The officer should also be placed on the Police Barring list.
- I am aware of the officer’s right to appeal in accordance with the Police Appeals Tribunal Rules 2020. The officer should provide notice of his intention to appeal to the Appropriate Authority within 10 working days of receipt of this written determination.
Vanessa Jardine
3rd November 2026